Home > Product Review > How to choose between compact speakers and column speakers?

How to choose between compact speakers and column speakers?

Modern technology offers a wide range of speakers. However, this profusion of brands and models can quickly turn into a real headache. How to choose your speakers when you are confused for choice? And especially what format to prefer between compact models and column speakers? Is the difference so important?

The answer is clearly yes, the difference being very marked, it seems important to us to provide clear answers to your questions and offer you the best possible advice. Let’s start with a first question, is it better to buy compact speakers or column type speakers? How to choose between compact speakers and column speakers?

Why choose a compact speaker?

The compact speakers are also called speaker type library, a name that may cause confusion. Indeed, it is not recommended to place compact speakers in a library. If you are looking for Optimal sound performance, it is best to use speaker stands (adding decoupling points will improve all the more the sound quality). While many enthusiasts prefer the term “standing speakers”, the phrase has never really been adopted, despite the fact that no audiophile would place its compact speakers in a library. The name has remained. These are can easily been used in small rooms or for domestic use in low price so here we have the list of best bookshelf speakers under 200, If you need the room or bookshelf speakers under low price you can easily select the one form above list.

The small footprint of these speakers allows you to position them on a buffet or ideally on a speaker stand. Their price is often lower than the model of the same range in column version. Finally, to sound a room of reduced size or for listening close monitoring / studio type the compact format of the speakers is ideal.

The musical differences between a compact speaker and a column model

The design and size of the speaker cabinet has a crucial impact on the sound reproduction. The larger the enclosure, the higher the risk of coloring the sound. One of the major objectives of the hi-fi is precisely to minimize this coloration in order to restore the music as it was recorded in the studio by the engineers. The design of many reference column speakers has been studied extensively to avoid this staining effect. Since compact speakers are, by definition, small in size, this risk of sound deterioration is much less important. As a result, the compact models deliver a punchier, more active sound with a host of details. This type of pregnant is able to marry rhythm and accuracy in a surprising way and many audiophiles believe that compact speakers offer a better sound image when compared to their column counterparts.

Positioning compact speakers

Placing a speaker in a room is an extremely important step in the process of implementing a stereo system. Compact speakers can be incredibly whimsical and sound very different depending on how close they are to a back wall or the floor and how they relate to the listener. Under no circumstances underestimate the impact that a pair of speaker stands can have on the final musical rendering.

To position a compact speaker at an ideal height, make sure that the tweeter is at the level of the ear, once the listener is in the listening position, sitting comfortably on his chair Or his sofa. That’s when the extremely practical side of compact speakers is revealed. Not only does their small size make them much easier to integrate into your interior, but you have to add to that the wide choice of speaker stands (sizes and shapes) allows you to easily adjust their height to the level that suits you best.

The convenience of the feet does not stop there: many models are hollow and can be filled with an inert material (sand for example) to ideally dampen unwanted vibrations. You can determine the filling of the feet yourself (how far to fill them and with what). By filling your speaker stands with a dense material such as sand, you weigh down the foot and thus ensure the stability of your speakers while giving “weight” to the sound. This type of filling enhances bass performance and gives compact speakers the degree of authority they can sometimes miss.

Column speakers

The column speaker are much larger than the compact speakers and do not require the use of feet. On the other hand, the addition of decoupling points or shock absorbers / absorbers of vibration is nonetheless recommended to effectively isolate the column speakers from the ground and thus annihilate any harmful vibration. Quality cabling is also a guarantee of optimization of the speaker power supply by the amp.

Column speakers: musical features

While compact speakers seem to have the upper hand in terms of detail and precision, column-type models stand out in terms of the scale of the sound stage. It is true that their bigger box can sometimes color more the music, however the column speakers of quality benefit from a studied design and a neat construction, in order to eliminate this phenomenon. That’s why entry-level column models are generally discouraged in favor of compact midrange speakers that will not suffer from this coloration. A quality column speaker will offer, at the cost of a slight loss of detail, a better bass response and a wider and deeper sound stage, for a truly immersive experience. The column speakers add to the purely audio dimension of compact speakers a real physical experience, a way to feel the sound impacts, whose intensity increases as you go up market.

Positioning the column speakers

One of the defects of column speakers – their bulkiness – is also to be one of their major assets. Since the speaker cabinet is designed to provide the best sound possible, you usually have nothing to do but add decoupling tips to get the best sound quality once you’ve placed the speakers in position.

On both sides of the listening area. While compact speakers require careful placement for perfect sound, placement is much less critical with column speakers. Despite a slight lack of versatility and a bulky size, column speakers are catching up thanks to their ease of placement.